When it comes to electric vehicles, Tata Motors has set the stage with two impressive contenders: the Nexon EV LR and the Curv EV 55. Both models bring Tata’s electric vehicle lineup to new heights, with distinctions that impact performance, handling, and ride quality. Here’s an in-depth comparison to help you understand how each car fares in various aspects, from cornering ability to acceleration, braking, and ride comfort.
1. Cornering Performance: Stability Meets Agility
We put both EVs through a cornering test to see how they handle under pressure. Starting with the Nexon EV LR, this compact electric SUV handled the first corner at 65 km/h with ease, maintaining stability and holding a tight line. However, when we pushed it to 70 km/h, it showed signs of drifting, with the rear end stepping out slightly, resulting in a minor cone strike.
The Curv EV 55, with its larger size and distinct design, demonstrated similar stability at 65 km/h, maintaining a clean line. At 70 km/h, while the Curvv experienced slight rear-end movement, it managed to navigate without striking any cones, proving a slight advantage in the cornering test. This gives the Curvv EV 55 the edge in handling stability at higher speeds.
2. Power and Acceleration: Lightweight vs. Horsepower
When it comes to power, the Curv EV 55 boasts a higher horsepower output compared to the Nexon EV LR. However, the Nexon EV LR benefits from a lighter curb weight, which gives it an edge in quick sprints and roll-on acceleration tests. From 0-100 km/h and 20-80 km/h, the Nexon EV LR demonstrated quicker response times, taking the lead in acceleration.
This difference becomes noticeable when both vehicles are driven in city traffic or during quick overtaking maneuvers, where the Nexon’s lighter frame allows it to react swiftly. The Curvv’s added power does contribute to its performance, but the Nexon ultimately excels in real-world, rapid acceleration situations.
3. Braking Performance: Control in Critical Moments
Braking tests from speeds of 100 km/h and 80 km/h highlighted each vehicle’s stopping power. The Nexon EV LR emerged as the winner, braking over a shorter distance compared to the Curvv EV 55. Despite this advantage, both models exhibited instances of brake fade after consecutive hard braking events, which could be something to consider for those planning regular high-speed commutes or long journeys.
4. Ride Comfort and Quality: Everyday Usability
Ride quality is a crucial factor in the day-to-day comfort of an EV. On our rough road test, we measured how well each car’s suspension absorbed bumps and vibrations. In this test, the Curv EV 55 performed admirably, preserving 460 mL of water in an onboard measurement test—indicating minimal movement and good absorption. The Nexon EV LR followed closely, saving 420 mL, showing that both cars are well-suited for rough road conditions.
In everyday driving scenarios, however, the Nexon EV LR appears to offer a better balance in suspension. It is comfortable on smooth roads and handles speed bumps and rough patches with ease. The Curvv EV 55, on the other hand, feels a bit firmer, with more side-to-side movement on uneven surfaces. This slight stiffness, while enhancing stability at high speeds, introduces a touch more harshness in the cabin over rugged terrains.
5. Cabin Noise Levels: Serenity Inside
Noise levels within the cabin also vary between these two EVs. Thanks to its design, the Curvv EV 55 provides a quieter cabin environment, keeping road noise to a minimum. The Nexon EV LR, though still relatively quiet, lets in a bit more sound, especially on rough roads. For long journeys or those seeking a serene cabin experience, the Curvv might have the upper hand.
6. Range Performance: Endurance for the Long Haul
One of the key factors in EV performance is range. With a larger battery, the Curvv EV 55 easily surpasses the Nexon EV LR in range, making it the clear winner for long-distance travel. In real-world range tests, the Curv provided impressive endurance, ideal for those planning extended road trips or commutes with fewer charging stops.
Final Verdict: Nexon EV LR vs. Curvv EV 55
Each model excels in different areas, making them ideal for distinct types of drivers. The Nexon EV LR shines in acceleration, braking, and daily ride comfort, offering a well-rounded experience with nimble handling and reliable braking. It’s an excellent choice for urban commuters and those who prioritize everyday usability.
The Curvv EV 55, with its superior cornering stability, quieter cabin, and extended range, appeals to drivers who seek high-speed stability and are inclined toward longer drives without frequent charging stops. Its firm suspension setup and quiet cabin enhance the driving experience on highways, though it may feel slightly stiffer on city roads.
In Summary:
- Nexon EV LR: Best suited for city driving with its agility, quick acceleration, and comfortable suspension.
- Curvv EV 55: Ideal for longer journeys with its superior range, cabin quietness, and cornering stability.
Whether you’re drawn to the Nexon EV LR’s everyday practicality or the Curvv EV 55’s long-haul performance, Tata’s electric lineup has something to meet your needs in the evolving EV market.
